· Wisconsin

Mama Rita's Pizzeria Menu

Browse Mama Rita's Pizzeria menu in Evansville, WI. See pizza, appetizers, BBQ, and pasta options, with available dine-in, takeout, and curbside pickup.

12 categories · 94 dishes 65 S Union St, Evansville, WI 53536, United States Last updated August 2026

View Restaurant Details

Location Evansville, WI

Menu Sections Appetizers, Pizzas, BBQ, Pasta, Drinks

Price Range $10 to $20

Service Options Curbside, Takeout, Dine-in

Popular For Lunch, Dinner, Solo dining

Accessibility Wheelchair parking available

Full menu

The full Mama Rita's Pizzeria menu

Browse every dish by category — from in-table BBQ cuts to stews, sides and drinks. Prices are shown where available.

Garlic Knots $10.00

6 jumbo Garlic knots coated in butter, parmesan and parsley. Served with Mama's Marinara.

Bread Sticks $9.00

Garlic and parmesan bread sticks with mamas marinara dipping sauce

Garlic Cheese Bread $12.00

Mamas Garlic cheese bread is back. 12" topped with garlic butter and 3 types of cheese. Served with Mama's Marinara.

Italian Beef $12.95

Italian spiced beef, soft hoagie roll, mozzarella cheese. Served with with hot or mild giardiniera.

Meatball Sub $10.95

Ardy Bros. Smoked Italian meatballs, with Mamas marinara and mozzarella cheese.

Mamas Lasagna $10.35

Build Your Own Pizza 12"

Pick your style of crust, sauce and toppings.

Meatball Madness 12"

Meatballs, Onion, Green Pepper, Mushrooms, Marinara

Blue Devil 12"

Ranch, Chicken, Bacon, Jalapeno, Roasted Red Pepper.

Meat Lovers 12"

Pepperoni, Sausage, Bacon, Canadian Bacon

Veggie Lovers 12"

Mushroom, Onion, Green Pepper, Red Pepper, Black Olive, Green Olive.

BBQ Chicken 12"

BBQ sauce, Chicken, Bacon, Red onion.

Trippple Porker 12"

BBQ sauce, Pulled Pork, Canadian Bacon, Bacon

Supreme 12"

Pepperoni, Sausage, Bacon, Canadian Bacon, Onion, Mushroom Green Pepper, Red Pepper, Black Olive, Green Olive.

Pork Mac Attack 12"

Creamy Mac and Cheese, BBQ sauce, Bacon, Ardy Bro's Pulled Pork.

Buffalo Chicken 12"

Buffalo sauce, smoked chicken, bacon, blue cheese crumbles.

Chicken Alfredo 12"

Smoked Chicken, creamy alfredo sauce, tomato, then sprinkled with our parmesan garlic topping.

Italian Stalian 12"

Marinara, Italian beef, Italian Sausage, Giardiniera

Mac And Cheese Pizza 12"

Creamy Mac and Cheese for the sauce topped with mozzarella and cheddar.

Apple Crisp Pizza 12" (Dessert)

Mike's Hot Honey Sausage & Pepperoni 12"

Build Your Own Pizza 16" $17.00

Pick your style of Crust, Sauce and toppings.

Meatball Madness 16" $24.00

Meatballs, Onion, Green Pepper, Mushrooms, Marinara.

Blue Devil 16" $24.00

Ranch, Chicken, Bacon, Jalapeno, Roasted Red Pepper.

Meat Lovers 16" $28.00

Pepperoni, Sausage, Bacon, Canadian Bacon

Veggie Lovers 16" $24.00

Tomato, Onion, Green Pepper, Red Pepper, Black Olive, Green Olive.

BBQ Chicken 16" $24.00

BBQ sauce, Chicken, Bacon, Red onion.

Trippple Porker 16" $28.00

BBQ, Pulled Pork, Canadian Bacon, Bacon

Supreme 16" $28.00

Pepperoni, Sausage, Bacon, Canadian Bacon, Onion, Mushroom Green Pepper, Red Pepper, Black Olive, Green Olive.

Pork Mac Attack 16" $24.00

Creamy Mac and Cheese, BBQ sauce, Bacon, Ardy Bro's Pulled Pork.

Buffalo Chicken 16" $24.00

Buffalo sauce, smoked chicken, bacon topped with blue cheese crumbles

Chicken Alfredo 16" $24.00

Creamy Alfredo sauce topped with smoked chicken, tomato and our parmesan garlic topping.

Italian Stallion 16" $24.00

Marinara, Italian beef, Italian Sausage, Giardiniera

Mac And Cheese Pizza 16" $20.00

Creamy Mac and Cheese for the sauce topped with mozzarella and cheddar.

Mike's Hot Honey And Pepperoni 16" $22.00

Meatballs In Sauce (Take And Heat) $17.95

1 lb smoked meatballs in 2lbs Mama's Marinara sauce. This is a cold product intended for you to use as you wish! ****Available Wed-Sunday***

Pulled Pork (Take And Heat)

Hickory smoked pork, pulled and ready to be reheated at your convenience.

Apple Pie Baked Beans (Take And Heat)

Our homemade Apple pie baked beans, made with pulled pork, apples, peppers and other goodies! ***This is a take and heat product. Fully cooked and ready for you to warm up as you please!***

Smoked Mac And Cheese (Take And Heat)

Ardy Bros. Smoked Mac and cheese is creamy and with the perfect amount of smoke. This is a take and heat product. Fully cooked and ready for you to warm up as you please!

Smoked Chicken (Take And Heat)

Slow smoked chicken. Take and heat or make into and awesome smoked chicken salad.

Cole Slaw

Home made creamy coleslaw available in 1/2 pint or full pint

Wednesday Ribs Dinner $29.95

1 Full rack of slow smoked St. Louis Style Ribs. 1 lb of smoked mac and cheese and 1/2 pound of coleslaw. Feeds 3- 4 people **Available for Wednesday only**

Thursday Night Chicken Dinner $18.95

Whole smoked cajun chicken with 1 lb mac and cheese and 1/2 pound slaw. Feeds 2-4 people.

Garlic Knots $10.00

6 jumbo Garlic knots coated in butter, parmesan and parsley. Served with Mama's Marinara.

Bread Sticks $9.00

Garlic and parmesan bread sticks with mamas marinara dipping sauce

Garlic Cheese Bread $12.00

Mamas Garlic cheese bread is back. 12" topped with garlic butter and 3 types of cheese. Served with Mama's Marinara.

Italian Beef $12.95

Italian spiced beef, soft hoagie roll, mozzarella cheese. Served with with hot or mild giardiniera.

Meatball Sub $10.95

Ardy Bros. Smoked Italian meatballs, with Mamas marinara and mozzarella cheese.

Mamas Lasagna $10.35

Build Your Own Pizza 12"

Pick your style of crust, sauce and toppings.

Meatball Madness 12"

Meatballs, Onion, Green Pepper, Mushrooms, Marinara

Blue Devil 12"

Ranch, Chicken, Bacon, Jalapeno, Roasted Red Pepper.

Meat Lovers 12"

Pepperoni, Sausage, Bacon, Canadian Bacon

Veggie Lovers 12"

Mushroom, Onion, Green Pepper, Red Pepper, Black Olive, Green Olive.

BBQ Chicken 12"

BBQ sauce, Chicken, Bacon, Red onion.

Trippple Porker 12"

BBQ sauce, Pulled Pork, Canadian Bacon, Bacon

Supreme 12"

Pepperoni, Sausage, Bacon, Canadian Bacon, Onion, Mushroom Green Pepper, Red Pepper, Black Olive, Green Olive.

Pork Mac Attack 12"

Creamy Mac and Cheese, BBQ sauce, Bacon, Ardy Bro's Pulled Pork.

Buffalo Chicken 12"

Buffalo sauce, smoked chicken, bacon, blue cheese crumbles.

Chicken Alfredo 12"

Smoked Chicken, creamy alfredo sauce, tomato, then sprinkled with our parmesan garlic topping.

Italian Stalian 12"

Marinara, Italian beef, Italian Sausage, Giardiniera

Mac And Cheese Pizza 12"

Creamy Mac and Cheese for the sauce topped with mozzarella and cheddar.

Apple Crisp Pizza 12" (Dessert)

Mike's Hot Honey Sausage & Pepperoni 12"

Build Your Own Pizza 16" $17.00

Pick your style of Crust, Sauce and toppings.

Meatball Madness 16" $24.00

Meatballs, Onion, Green Pepper, Mushrooms, Marinara.

Blue Devil 16" $24.00

Ranch, Chicken, Bacon, Jalapeno, Roasted Red Pepper.

Meat Lovers 16" $28.00

Pepperoni, Sausage, Bacon, Canadian Bacon

Veggie Lovers 16" $24.00

Tomato, Onion, Green Pepper, Red Pepper, Black Olive, Green Olive.

BBQ Chicken 16" $24.00

BBQ sauce, Chicken, Bacon, Red onion.

Trippple Porker 16" $28.00

BBQ, Pulled Pork, Canadian Bacon, Bacon

Supreme 16" $28.00

Pepperoni, Sausage, Bacon, Canadian Bacon, Onion, Mushroom Green Pepper, Red Pepper, Black Olive, Green Olive.

Pork Mac Attack 16" $24.00

Creamy Mac and Cheese, BBQ sauce, Bacon, Ardy Bro's Pulled Pork.

Buffalo Chicken 16" $24.00

Buffalo sauce, smoked chicken, bacon topped with blue cheese crumbles

Chicken Alfredo 16" $24.00

Creamy Alfredo sauce topped with smoked chicken, tomato and our parmesan garlic topping.

Italian Stallion 16" $24.00

Marinara, Italian beef, Italian Sausage, Giardiniera

Mac And Cheese Pizza 16" $20.00

Creamy Mac and Cheese for the sauce topped with mozzarella and cheddar.

Mike's Hot Honey And Pepperoni 16" $22.00

Meatballs In Sauce (Take And Heat) $17.95

1 lb smoked meatballs in 2lbs Mama's Marinara sauce. This is a cold product intended for you to use as you wish! ****Available Wed-Sunday***

Pulled Pork (Take And Heat)

Hickory smoked pork, pulled and ready to be reheated at your convenience.

Apple Pie Baked Beans (Take And Heat)

Our homemade Apple pie baked beans, made with pulled pork, apples, peppers and other goodies! ***This is a take and heat product. Fully cooked and ready for you to warm up as you please!***

Smoked Mac And Cheese (Take And Heat)

Ardy Bros. Smoked Mac and cheese is creamy and with the perfect amount of smoke. This is a take and heat product. Fully cooked and ready for you to warm up as you please!

Smoked Chicken (Take And Heat)

Slow smoked chicken. Take and heat or make into and awesome smoked chicken salad.

Cole Slaw

Home made creamy coleslaw available in 1/2 pint or full pint

Wednesday Ribs Dinner $29.95

1 Full rack of slow smoked St. Louis Style Ribs. 1 lb of smoked mac and cheese and 1/2 pound of coleslaw. Feeds 3- 4 people **Available for Wednesday only**

Thursday Night Chicken Dinner $18.95

Whole smoked cajun chicken with 1 lb mac and cheese and 1/2 pound slaw. Feeds 2-4 people.

Prices & availability

Menu prices and availability at Mama Rita's Pizzeria may vary by season or day. Some menu categories and dishes might change over time, and item-level prices should be confirmed when ordering. The menu includes multiple pizza sizes, appetizers, BBQ options, and drinks.

Dining fit

This menu is good for

Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining
Comfort food
Catering
Casual atmosphere

About this menu

Mama Rita's Pizzeria offers a menu focused on classic comfort food with a variety of pizza sizes including 12" and 16" options, alongside appetizers like Italian Beef and Meatball Subs. The menu further includes BBQ offerings and pasta dishes, organized into clear categories to aid selection. Guests often mention favorites such as the Pork Mac Attack and BBQ Chicken pizzas, reflecting the menu’s blend of traditional and distinctive pizza styles.

The menu supports convenient ordering through curbside pickup, takeout, or dine-in experiences in a casual setting. This flexibility makes it suitable for lunch, dinner, and solo dining occasions. Availability of free parking and wheelchair accessible amenities adds to the ease of visiting this Evansville restaurant.