· New Jersey

Prime 374 - Seafood & Steak Menu

Explore the menu of Prime 374 - Seafood & Steak in West Milford, NJ. Find seafood, steak, brunch, sides, and beverages. Menu and prices may change.

13 categories · 132 dishes 374 Morsetown Rd, West Milford, NJ 07480, United States Last updated August 2026

View Restaurant Details

Restaurant Prime 374 - Seafood & Steak

Rating 4.6 (171 Reviews)

Price Range $50 to $100

Location West Milford, NJ

Service Options Dine-in, Takeout, Curbside pickup

Open Hours Tue-Sat 4PM-11PM, Sun 11AM-9PM

Full menu

The full Prime 374 - Seafood & Steak menu

Browse every dish by category — from in-table BBQ cuts to stews, sides and drinks. Prices are shown where available.

Southwestern Salad $26.00

Blackened chicken breast with romaine, avocado, corn, shredded cheddar, tomatoes & ranch dressing.

Wedge Salad $15.00

Crisp iceberg topped with crumbled bleu cheese, tomatoes, bacon bits & bleu cheese dressing.

Caprese Salad $15.00

Fresh mozzarella, tomatoes, basil.

Prime Crab Salad $30.00

Grilled shrimp, lump crab meat, avocado, roasted peppers & onions, topped with bleu cheese & vinaigrette.

Caesar Salad $14.00

Crisp romaine with our homemade Caesar dressing, Parmesan cheese & croutons.

Mixed Green Salad $14.00

Tomatoes, cucumbers, onions, vinaigrette.

Ari's Cold Seafood Salad $30.00

Shrimp, calamari, octopus, lettuce, peppers, celery, lemon, olive oil & mayo.

Skirt Steak Salad $30.00

Mixed greens, tomatoes, crumbled bleu cheese, vinaigrette dressing.

Mediterranean Salad $15.00

Chopped Tomatoes, Cucumbers, Bell Peppers, Red Onions, Black Olives, Feta Cheese, Oregano, Greens & Vinaigrette

10 Oz Filet Mignon $65.00

Chilean Sea Bass $42.00

Shrimp Classics $32.00

Fried, scampi, parmigiana, francese, Marsala, piccata, or fra diavolo.

Balsamic Chicken $26.00

Chicken breast with bell pepper mix & onions in a balsamic reduction sauce.

18 Oz Berkshire Pork Chop $40.00

Sautéed with cherry peppers scarpariello style.

Grilled Skirt Steak USDA Prime $42.00

Chicken Classics $26.00

Parmigiana, Francese, Marsala, piccata, or scarpariello.

Chicken Rollatini $26.00

Stuffed with spinach & mozzarella in a creamy brandy sauce with portobello mushrooms.

Drunken Salmon $34.00

Shrimp & portobello mushrooms in a creamy cognac sauce.

Grilled Lamb Chops $49.00

22 Oz Grilled Ribeye USDA Prime $65.00

Dry Aged Porterhouse $140.00

For two.

Chicken Martini $26.00

Parmesan crusted chicken in a white wine, lemon & butter sauce.

Broiled Salmon $32.00

White wine & lemon sauce.

Slow Roasted Baby Back Ribs $26.00

Rubbed with barbecue sauce (half rack or full rack).

Grilled Skirt Steak $44.00

Certified Angus Beef

Broiled Halibut $45.00

Surf & Turf $99.00

10 Oz. Filet Mignon & 8 Oz. Lobster Tail

Prime Filet Mignon 10oz $60.00

Grilled Ribeye USDA Prime $75.00

Dry Aged 24 oz.

Porterhouse Steak For Two 44 Oz. $145.00

USDA Prime, Dry Aged

Berkshire Pork Chop 20 Oz. $44.00

Sautéed with cherry peppers scarpariello style.

Broiled Chilean Sea Bass $48.00

Broiled 8 Oz. Twin Lobster Tails $80.00

Sizzling Canadian Bacon $15.00

Angus Beef Sliders (3 Pcs) $18.00

American Cheese

Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail $22.00

Steamed shrimp with cocktail sauce & lemon.

PEI Mussels $18.00

Choice of white wine, marinara, or fra diavolo.

Fried Calamari $20.00

Sautéed with cherry peppers.

Fried Avocado & Grilled Shrimp $22.00

Mango salsa & chipotle mayo.

Blue Point Oysters $18.00

Cocktail or Rockefeller (6 or 12 pcs).

Colossal Crab Meat Cocktail $28.00

Spiedini Alla Romana $18.00

Cheesy Loaf in a White Wine Caper Sauce

Baked Clams $24.00

12 pcs.

Cold Seafood Cocktail For Two $58.00

6 clams, 6 oysters, 4 shrimp & crab meat.

Coconut Shrimp $22.00

Fried Shrimp, Coconut Flakes Crusted

Little Neck Clams $24.00

Choice of white wine, marinara, or fra diavolo (6 or 12 pcs).

Grilled Octopus $25.00

Lemon, olive oil, red vinegar & oregano.

Meatballs Marinara $16.00

Grilled Calamari $18.00

White wine & lemon sauce.

Caprese Salad $15.00

Fresh mozzarella, tomatoes, basil.

Canadian Bacon Slab $14.00

French Toast With Strawberries $18.00

Bacon or sausage.

Eggs Florentine With Home Fries $18.00

Poached eggs with spinach & hollandaise sauce.

Skirt Steak & Eggs With Home Fries $34.00

Served with ice cream.

Eggs Benedict $18.00

Poached eggs with bacon & hollandaise sauce.

Avocado Omelet With Bacon & Cheddar $18.00

Served with home fries.

Quesadillas With Home Fries $18.00

Eggs, diced peppers, bacon & cheddar cheese.

Salmon Bearnaise With Home Fries $32.00

Chicken & Waffles $26.00

Two Eggs With Home Fries $18.00

Served with bacon or sausage.

10 Oz Angus Burger With Fried Egg & Avocado $18.00

Served with French fries.

Raspberry Frozen Drink Virgin $10.00

Juices $4.00

Orange Juice, Pineapple Juice, Shirley Temple

Virgin Mary $10.00

Mango Frozen Drink Virgin $10.00

Aqua Pana Mineral Water L $8.00

Coffee $3.00

Chocolate Milk $4.00

Peach Frozen Drink Virgin $10.00

Strawberry Daiquiri Virgin $10.00

Pinacolada Virgin $10.00

Passion Fruit Smoothie $10.00

Pelegrino Sparkling Water L $8.00

Cappuccino $5.00

Espresso $3.00

Soft Drinks $3.00

Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite, Ginger Ale, Sweet Ice Tea, Unsweetened Ice Tea, Lemonade, Cranberry Juice, Tonic Water

Sautéed Broccoli $10.00

Garlic Mash $8.00

Sweet Potato Fries $8.00

French Fries $8.00

Onion Rings $8.00

Coleslaw $8.00

Sautéed Spinach $10.00

Sautéed Mushrooms $8.00

Jumbo Baked Potatoes $8.00

Hand-Cut Potato Chips $8.00

Toasted Mac N' Cheese $12.00

Garlic Bread $8.00

Mixed Sautéed Veggies $10.00

Crispy Brussels Sprouts $12.00

Rice Pilaf $8.00

Potato Chips $10.00

Side Mac N' Cheese $15.00

Baked Potatoes $10.00

Seafood Linguine $32.00

Clams, mussels, shrimp, calamari in a light fra diavolo sauce.

Linguine Nero $34.00

Black linguine with lobster meat, shrimp, white wine, lemon & butter sauce.

Linguine Clam Sauce $28.00

White or red fresh clam sauce.

Penne Vesa $26.00

Chunks of chicken, sautéed with cherry & bell peppers & spicy marinara.

Capellini Contadina $26.00

Vegan. Eggplant, asparagus, fresh mozzarella, sun-dried tomatoes in a rich marinara sauce.

Linguine Aragosta $34.00

Lobster meat & shrimp, parsley, alfredo sauce.

Penne Pesto $26.00

Chicken, fresh mozzarella, sun dried tomatoes, asparagus in a creamy pesto sauce.

Penne Alla Vodka $22.00

Add chicken, shrimp or steak for an additional charge.

Spaghetti & Meatballs $26.00

Rigatoni Donna $34.00

Mezzi Rigatoni with Diced Salmon, Shrimp, Scallions, Tomatoes in a Lobster Sauce

Menu highlights

Guests often mention

Blue Point Oysters

Espresso Martini

Linguine Nero

Prime Filet Mignon 10oz

Prime Rib Eye

Spare Ribs

Prices & availability

Menu availability, seasonal dishes, and prices at Prime 374 may vary. Detailed item-level prices are not fully provided and may need confirmation when ordering. Menu categories include seafood, steak, brunch, sides, and beverages.

Dining fit

This menu is good for

Dinner
Happy Hour Drinks
Groups
Wine
Kids' Menu
Cozy Atmosphere

About this menu

The menu at Prime 374 - Seafood & Steak features a diverse selection of seafood and steak options alongside brunch, pasta, soups, salads, sides, and bar dishes. Guests often mention popular dishes like Blue Point Oysters, Prime Filet Mignon, and Prime Rib Eye, highlighting a menu that balances comfort food with upscale dining. The categories are clearly structured, enabling easy browsing of small plates, entrées, and beverages including cocktails and wine.

This menu suits those seeking a casual yet refined dining experience suitable for lunch, dinner, or special occasions. Practical dining options include dine-in, takeout, and curbside pickup, with no delivery available. Reservations are recommended, especially for dinner and private events.