· Wyoming

Brooklyn’s Tavern Menu

Browse the menu of Brooklyn’s Tavern, an Italian and pizza restaurant in Wheatland, WY. Explore pizza, subs, desserts, and drinks with prices from $10 to $20.

6 categories · 21 dishes 877 Gilchrist St, Wheatland, WY 82201, United States Last updated August 2026

View Restaurant Details

Cuisine Italian, Pizza

Price Range $10 - $20

Rating 4.7 (65 Reviews)

Service Takeout, Dine-in

Hours Tue-Sat 4 PM - 9 PM

Location 877 Gilchrist St, Wheatland, WY

Menu photos

A look at the dishes

Full menu

The full Brooklyn’s Tavern menu

Browse every dish by category — from in-table BBQ cuts to stews, sides and drinks. Prices are shown where available.

Prices & availability

Menu prices at Brooklyn’s Tavern generally range from $10 to $20, but item-level prices may vary or require confirmation. Menu categories and item availability, including specialty pizzas and subs, can change seasonally or by day. Customers are encouraged to check current offerings before visiting or ordering.

Dining fit

This menu is good for

Lunch
Dinner
Beer & Cocktails
Groups
Solo Dining
30 min - 2 hr Visit

About this menu

Brooklyn’s Tavern offers a casual Italian dining experience focused on pizza, subs, and a few dessert options. The menu features several specialty pizzas such as Buffalo Chicken, Margherita, and Meatball Parmesan, alongside classic build-your-own and sheet pizzas. Subs include traditional Italian and Meatball options. Drinks range from soda and water to a notable selection of beer, cocktails, and wine.

Guests often mention the authentic New York-style pizza and the quality of ingredients, with fast, friendly service contributing to a welcoming atmosphere. The menu categories clearly separate pizza varieties, subs, desserts, and sauces, making it straightforward for customers to browse and order via takeout or dine-in.